Court: SD Tx 07/14/2020 Court Dismisses Extra-Contractual Claims in UIM Dispute Court determines that Brainard and Menchaca preclude extra-contractual claims until liability is established in UIM context. Reviewing the Case Document is for members only. Please login motion to dismissfailure to state a claimextra-contractual liabilityMenchacaUIM coverageBrainardAutomobile liability insurance policy